The Date Was Never the Expensive Part

It is a Saturday, and you are doing arithmetic you did not plan to do. The waiter has just set down the bill at a cafe on SG Highway. Two cold coffees, a plate of something you both pretended to want, and somewhere between the GST line and the tip your brain runs a quiet tally of the month. Four dates. Maybe five. None of them went anywhere. The number you land on is not enormous by Mumbai standards. It is large enough, though, to make you sit there for a second and wonder what exactly you have been buying.

The cost of dating in India is a thing people say out loud now, without lowering their voice. It used to be a slightly shameful admission, the kind of thing you only confessed to the friend who already knew your bank balance. Now it is a whole genre. The brunch that costs more than your electricity bill. The mocktail that, thanks to prohibition in Gujarat and pure markup everywhere else, somehow lands at three hundred rupees. The Uber there and the Uber back. Multiply it by a search that has no obvious end, and you start to understand why a generation has decided to opt out of the whole pricing structure.

The Generation That Ran the Numbers

A 2025 Bank of America study found that roughly half of Gen Z men and women in the US now spend close to nothing on dates in a given month. Another quarter of the men, and thirty percent of the women, keep it under a hundred dollars. That is not a small shift in behaviour. That is a generation looking at the menu and deciding the menu is the problem.

It is American data, and dollars are not rupees, but the instinct travels intact. Ask anyone in their late twenties in Bangalore or Pune what a date costs and watch them do the math reflexively, the way you check your balance before a long weekend. They are carrying rent that eats forty percent of a salary, the low hum of a job market that promises less than the one their seniors walked into, and a family WhatsApp group that treats "settling down" as a financial event with a fixed deposit attached. Of course they got careful. Careful is the rational response to a world that keeps quietly raising the price of everything, including affection.

And the careful ones figured something out that the rest of us are slow to admit. Spending less can make dating better. A walk through Kankaria at dusk costs nothing and reveals more about a person than a tasting menu ever will. Filter coffee at a darshini in Indiranagar tells you whether someone can be happy in a plastic chair. The frugal date is not the sad date. Half the time it is the honest one, because nobody is performing for the bill.

The Bill Was Never the Expensive Part

Here is where the conversation usually stops, satisfied with itself. Find the cheaper option. Redirect the saving into an emergency fund. Date like a person who reads personal finance threads. It is good advice as far as it goes.

It just stops one layer too early.

Because if you go back to that Saturday on SG Highway and look at the number again, the rupees were never the heavy part of it. Four dates that went nowhere is not a story about four cold coffees. It is a story about four Saturday evenings, four times you got your hopes up on a Wednesday, four conversations that started with effort and ended with a message left on read. You can swap the cafe for a park and you have changed almost nothing about that, because the expensive part of dating was never the bill. It was the fourth coffee with someone who was never going to be honest about who they were.

That is the line nobody puts in the budgeting advice. You were never overspending on dates. You were overspending on the wrong people.

The Real Tax Is Volume

Conventional dating apps are not built to reduce that overspend. They are built to increase it. The entire revenue model rests on you swiping, matching, talking, hoping, and coming back to do it again, because the moment you actually find someone, you stop being a customer. Every boost you buy, every premium tier that promises better visibility, is a tax you pay for the privilege of more volume. More matches. More chats. More first dates that were statistically never going to be the last one.

And in India the tax has a particular flavour. There is the man on the other end whose photos are five years and one marriage out of date. The profile that turns out to be three personalities sharing one account. The person who was charming for two weeks and then, on the actual date, was a stranger you had paid to meet. You do not find out any of this until you are already sitting across the table, already an hour into your evening, already committed to the bill you came here to avoid. The catfish is not a money problem. The catfish is a time-and-self problem, which is the only currency that does not refill.

This is the part of the cost that frugal dating advice cannot touch, because it is not on the receipt. You can pick the cheapest cafe in Ahmedabad and still walk out of it having spent the one thing you cannot get a discount on, which is the version of you that showed up hopeful.

So the real question is not how to make each date cheaper. It is how to stop paying, again and again, for the privilege of finding out too late.

That is a sourcing problem, not a budgeting one. It is solved before the date, not at the table. It is solved by knowing the person across from you is actually the person from the profile, verified against a government ID rather than a flattering angle. It is solved by being structurally unable to spread yourself across fourteen lukewarm chats at once, because the system caps your attention at three and forces you to mean it. The economics flip the moment volume stops being the product.

Cheap Was Always the Wrong Word

There is a quiet snobbery in calling someone cheap for being careful with money. The London couple in that original story were not being cheap. They were being deliberate, and deliberate looks like frugal only to people who confuse spending with caring.

The same word does the same disservice to your dating life. Being selective is not stinginess. It is the opposite of stinginess. It is deciding that your Saturdays are worth too much to hand out at random.

What Frugal Should Actually Mean

If you wanted to date frugally in the way that actually changes your year, you would not start with the venue. You would start with the funnel.

You would spend less time and meet fewer people, on purpose. You would treat the first filter as the one that matters, the way a careful person treats the big monthly outflows instead of agonising over the cost of coffee. You would rather have three conversations with people who are real and serious than thirty with people who are neither. You would, in short, do to your dating life what Gen Z already did to their date nights, which is refuse the version where you pay full price for less than you wanted.

The cream-coloured irony of all this is that the women in these stories were ahead of everyone. They always spent more carefully, because the cost of a wrong date was never just financial for them. Pinnaya is built around that instinct rather than against it. Women's photos stay private until a real conversation has happened, so the first thing a man invests is attention and not a swipe. The whole thing runs slower and means more, which is what every frugal person eventually learns to want.

What You Are Actually Saving

Go back, one last time, to the bill on SG Highway. Imagine the same month with a different shape. Not five dates with strangers who fizzled. Two, with people who were verified to be exactly who they claimed, chosen out of a small and serious few rather than an endless feed. You might have spent the same rupees. You did not spend the same Saturdays. You did not spend the same hope.

The frugal generation got the principle right and the line item wrong. They learned that you do not have to spend big to fall for someone. The next thing to learn is that the money was never the big spend. Your time was. Your hope was. The cheapest date in India is not the one at the park instead of the rooftop. It is the one you were never going to regret, with someone who was real before you ever picked up the bill.

The cheapest date is the one with someone who is exactly who they said.

Pinnaya verifies every profile through government ID, and it caps you at three active matches at a time. Your evenings go to people who were real to begin with, and there are few enough of them to actually mean something.

Visit Pinnaya.com | Download on iOS | Download on Android